SPEND IDEAS
A Guide To Incentive Pay And How To Use It Effectively

Motivate your team and achieve business goals with incentive pay. Learn how to incorporate incentives into your sales compensation program.

Tom Dixon
Content Manager
Motivate your team and achieve business goals with incentive pay. Learn how to incorporate incentives into your sales compensation program.

Incentive pay encourages employees to stretch their skills to hit high goals.

By linking pay directly to performance, it motivates your sales team to push beyond their limits. When they hit those challenging targets and earn their rewards, it shifts their mindset. What was difficult becomes routine, which drives them to aim even higher.

However, successful incentive pay programs require more than just setting ambitious goals. They must be part of a holistic strategy that includes a great product, a clear target market, and a talented sales team. When these pieces come together, an incentive pay plan becomes the spark that ignites your team's potential and propels your company to new heights.

What Is Incentive Pay

Incentive pay is an effective tool for sales teams.
Photo by LinkedIn Sales Solutions on Unsplash

Incentive pay rewards employees above and beyond their base salary for achieving specific goals or milestones.

This additional compensation aligns an employee’s financial interests with the company's by tying compensation to performance metrics that drive business success. In fact, a 2024 CaptivateIQ survey of more than 1,000 commissionable employees found 57 percent felt incentive pay inspired them to do a better job at work.

Businesses use this compensation strategy to motivate employees to work towards common goals and share in the rewards of their efforts.

Some types of incentive pay plans include:

  • Bonuses: A lump sum payment for hitting specific targets.
  • Commissions: A percentage of sales revenue earned by an employee.
  • Profit-sharing: A portion of the company's profits distributed among employees.
  • Stock options: The right to purchase company shares at a set price, often rewarding long-term performance.

While incentive payments are most common in sales roles, it can be applied in any position where employee or team actions have measurable outcomes.

5 Examples Of Incentive Pay Structure To Consider

There are many ways to incorporate incentive pay into your sales compensation strategy.
Photo by LinkedIn Sales Solutions on Unsplash

The right types of incentives for your sales compensation program will depend on your company’s goals, culture, and employee preferences. These are some of the most common approaches:

1. Cash bonus 

Cash bonuses are a straightforward way to reward employees for their excellent work, often coming in the form of signing bonuses, performance bonuses, or year-end bonuses. 

While cash provides a tangible financial reward, it may lack the personal touch and thoughtfulness of other incentive options. If added to a regular paycheck, cash bonuses can also go unnoticed, especially if employees have direct deposit set up.

2. Commission

Commissions are a type of compensation typically based on sales volume or the number of new customers acquired. This structure aligns employee incentives with company goals, encouraging them to maximize their sales efforts. 

However, commissions can sometimes lead to a narrow focus on short-term results rather than long-term customer relationships and may not be suitable for all roles.

3. Spot Bonuses

Spot bonuses are spontaneous monetary rewards given to employees for outstanding performance or going above and beyond in their work. 

These bonuses are typically smaller in scale compared to other incentive structures and are designed to provide immediate employee recognition for a job well done. 

While spot bonuses can be effective in acknowledging specific achievements, they may not have the same long-term impact as more structured incentive programs.

4. Points-Based Recognition Programs

Points-based recognition programs allow employees to earn points for their achievements and redeem them for rewards of their choosing, such as merchandise, gift cards, or experiences. 

These programs offer flexibility and empower employees to select meaningful rewards. However, the rewards catalog may not always align with every employee's preferences, and the redemption process can sometimes feel impersonal or transactional.

5. Giftly Cards

Giftly is the perfect tool to use when you need to send a quarterly bonus, a recurring referral payment, or an always-on referral bonus.

Employees can redeem Giftly cards on any experience, service, or product they want, which makes them more flexible than traditional gift cards. At the same time, Giftly cards can be customized with unique designs, images, and messages, so each incentive is more thoughtful and personalized than cash.

This personal approach also feels a little bit different than cash bonuses. It’s more likely to create an environment where coworkers celebrate each others’ wins, rather than view incentives with envy.

Advantages Of Incentive Pay

There are many advantages of incentive pay.
Photo by LinkedIn Sales Solutions on Unsplash

When designed and implemented effectively, an incentive pay program can drive significant improvements in employee performance, engagement, and business results. 

Increased Motivation

By tying compensation directly to performance, incentive pay creates a powerful motivator for employees. 

When employees know their efforts will be rewarded financially, they're more likely to go the extra mile to achieve sales goals. This boost in motivation can lead to higher employee productivity, better quality work, and a stronger commitment to the company's success.

Improved Performance

Incentive pay encourages employees to focus on the metrics that matter most to the business. Whether it's increasing sales revenue, improving customer satisfaction, or boosting efficiency, a well-designed incentive program can drive measurable improvements in key performance indicators (KPIs). 

By aligning individual performance with business objectives, incentive pay helps ensure that everyone is working towards the same goals.

Increased Engagement And Job Satisfaction

When employees feel their hard work is recognized and rewarded, they're more likely to be engaged and satisfied with their jobs. 

Incentive compensation plans send a clear message that the company values their contributions and is willing to invest in their success. This approach fosters a positive work culture and reduces turnover, saving the company time and money in the long run.

Enhanced Teamwork and Collaboration

While individual incentives are common, team-based incentives can also be highly effective. 

By rewarding groups for achieving collective goals, you encourage collaboration, communication, and a shared sense of purpose. Team incentives can break down silos between departments, fostering a more cohesive and cooperative work environment.

Adaptable To Changing Priorities

Incentive-based compensation programs can be tailored to meet the specific needs and goals of your organization. Whether you want to drive short-term sales growth or encourage long-term customer loyalty, you can design an incentive structure that aligns with your priorities.

Drawbacks

It's important to take care to mitigate some of the potential drawbacks of incentive pay.
Photo by LinkedIn Sales Solutions on Unsplash

Implementing an incentive program requires careful planning and ongoing monitoring to avoid unintended consequences. Here are some of the key challenges to consider:

Overemphasis on Short-Term Goals

If not designed carefully, incentive pay programs can lead employees to prioritize short-term gains over long-term success. 

For example, a sales representative might push hard to close deals before the end of a quarter to earn a bonus, but neglect to build the strong customer relationships that lead to repeat business. This shortsightedness can ultimately harm the company's reputation and bottom line.

Increased Stress and Burnout

High-pressure incentive programs can take a toll on employee well-being. When compensation is heavily tied to employee performance, employees may feel constant pressure to meet targets, leading to increased stress, anxiety, and even burnout. This is particularly true if goals are unrealistic or if the incentive structure creates a cutthroat, competitive environment.

Unintended Behavioral Consequences

Poorly designed incentive programs can sometimes encourage unethical or counterproductive behavior. For example, if a customer service representative's bonus is tied to the number of calls handled per hour, they may rush through interactions or provide subpar service to meet their quota. 

Similarly, if a salesperson's commission is based solely on revenue, they may push products that aren't in the customer's best interest.

Perceived Unfairness

Incentive pay can create a sense of inequity if not managed properly. If the criteria for earning rewards are unclear or if the program seems to favor certain employees over others, it can lead to feelings of resentment and demotivation. This is particularly challenging when incentivizing team members with diverse roles and responsibilities.

Craft an Incentive Pay Program That Inspires and Rewards

Ultimately, the key to a successful incentive pay program is balance. By carefully weighing the advantages and potential pitfalls, and crafting a program that aligns with your company's values and performance goals, you can harness the power of incentives to drive performance and growth.

When selecting an incentive pay structure, consider the unique needs and preferences of your organization and employees. While cash bonuses, commissions, and traditional bonuses have their place, Giftly cards provide a compelling alternative that combines the benefits of personalization, flexibility, and tangible recognition. 

If you’re looking to create a well-rounded and effective incentive program for your team, let’s talk.

giftly stories

Discover more